Devin Williams' trade to the New York Yankees meant a significant change in appearance due to the team's strict facial hair policy, a legacy of former owner George Steinbrenner. The policy prohibits any facial hair below the lower lip. This meant the star closer had to shave his beard, resulting in a dramatically different look for the player. Williams' clean-shaven face was a stark contrast, prompting reactions from fans on social media. However, after a short time in Tampa, Williams was seen sporting some stubble, drawing attention and comments from Yankee fans online.

Paul Goldschmidt, another new Yankee, also had to adhere to the policy, leading to remarks about his changed appearance. When questioned about shaving, Williams simply stated, "It is what it is," acknowledging the first time he'd shaved his beard in six years. He had even initially arrived at camp unshaven.

While some Yankee legends like Don Mattingly and Goose Gossage sported mustaches, beards have been a point of contention. CC Sabathia famously grew a small beard in response to former prospect Clint Frazier's long hair, which also violated team rules. Sabathia has maintained his beard since retiring, and even Derek Jeter now sports facial hair. Many Yankees players grow beards during the offseason or after leaving the team.

This long-standing policy famously led to Johnny Damon's makeover in 2005, and reportedly influenced the Yankees' decision not to pursue closer Brian Wilson over a decade ago due to his iconic beard.