An eighth-grader's persistence, backed by legal intervention, has led to a New York public school district reversing its decision and allowing the formation of a student-led Bible club. Elijah Nelson, a student at Waterville Jr./Sr. High School, had initially been denied permission to establish the club, with the school claiming it couldn't sponsor any religiously affiliated groups.

For two years, Nelson sought to create the club, facing resistance from the school. While initially offered informal lunchtime meetings under staff supervision or the option to apply as an outside organization, Nelson's request for official recognition was denied. The school had argued that formally acknowledging the club would constitute an unconstitutional endorsement of religion.

However, after the involvement of lawyers and the First Liberty Institute (FLI), the Waterville Central School District announced it would officially establish the Bible Study Club at its upcoming school board meeting. Superintendent Dr. Jennifer Spring admitted that Nelson had been given "inaccurate" information, emphasizing the school's commitment to providing diverse opportunities for students.

Representing Nelson, FLI, along with attorneys from Jones Day law firm, sent a letter to the school district arguing that the denial violated Nelson's First Amendment rights. They contended that the school's interpretation of the Establishment Clause was outdated and that neutrality, not exclusion, was required. The letter emphasized that the government cannot discriminate against religious groups when providing benefits.

Before the reversal, Nelson's father expressed his confusion over the school's treatment of religious students, highlighting the desire for tolerance and inclusivity. Keisha Russell, senior counsel at First Liberty, initially condemned the school's actions as unlawful discrimination. Following the district's announcement, she expressed hope that they would follow through with their commitment.